Skip to main content

How to deal when your cat brings you dead animals

We understand. You love your cat, and you feed her well. So, when your cat decides to catch and kill a mouse or other small animal, it can be hard to comprehend, especially when she brings the catch to you and lays it, with pride, at your feet.

Why would a well-fed, well-loved member of the family choose to behave like this? Cats think a dead mouse is a gift, even though it’s not one their human family members typically appreciate. You can’t stop the habit completely, but here are some tips to slow down the constant parade of dead animals into your home.

gray cat on hunt in grass
Image used with permission by copyright holder

About that cat of yours

She’s a natural hunter. The instinct to eye, stalk, pounce, grab, and then kill is innate. In fact, early accounts of human and cat interaction suggest that Egyptians partnered with wildcats because they kept their granaries free from rodents.

Recommended Videos

Cats were eventually domesticated by the Egyptians as early as 1500 B.C. and proclaimed sacred animals in the fifth and sixth dynasties. Some say, based on ancient Egyptian drawings, that the tabby cat may be a direct descendant.

Millennia later, these true carnivores still thrive on hunting and killing their meals, no matter how tame they’ve become. Cats need to eat meat to survive. That’s why commercial cat food contains taurine, an amino acid found in animal proteins that is necessary for the health of your cat’s vision, digestion, heart muscles, and immune system.

Why do cats bring you dead animals?

It’s a gift in the truest sense. Your cat considers you family, and as such, it’s her responsibility to provide for you. It’s also her way of teaching you how to hunt for yourself.

One of the ways cats in the wild — big and small — teach their young survival skills is by bringing home injured or dead animals. Domesticated cats like yours are still natural parents and teachers. Even if she’s spayed or never had a litter of kittens, your female cat may still exhibit these natural tendencies with her adopted human family.

Besides, it’s fun. What good is having all this talent if you can’t exercise it? Stalking, chasing, and pouncing are all elements of cat play. Expensive catnip and wand toys aside, the thrill of actually chasing and catching a live object is much more exciting. Her offering may merely be a way of showing you her latest trophy so that you can praise her as a mighty huntress.

gray cat with little mouse

How to decrease the slaughter

Although receiving dead animals as gifts is unsavory at best, realize your cat is happy and healthy. And she loves you. Her constant gifts are simply her way of exercising the hunting-and-providing characteristics her ancestors have passed along.

Since these are highly evolved tendencies, trying to completely squelch this behavior could be stressful for your cat (and totally frustrating for you). Instead, look for ways to minimize the risk to the small animals in your yard while exercising your cat’s instinct to hunt and provide. Here are a few tips:

  • Put a bell on her collar. This will make it more difficult for her to sneak up on birds and rodents in the first place.
  • Keep your cat inside just before sunrise and sunset. That’s when small rodents are most likely to be out and about.
  • Restrict access to any bird feeders or birdbaths in your yard. Place them in areas she can’t get to or at a height she won’t attempt to reach.
  • Keep rodents out of her space. Check the interior and exterior of your home for any holes or spaces where they might enter. Store all food in airtight containers to prevent temptation and infestation.
  • Fulfill her need to chase and capture with interactive toys. Wand and kick toys that satisfy her prey drive are good ways to indulge her natural urges without causing harm to another living animal.

So, how should you accept future gifts? Graciously, especially when they come from your well-meaning cat. Praise her, then discreetly dispose of it as soon as possible. Whether the gift is parental, charitable, or simply instinctual, it’s a natural part of being a cat she simply can’t ignore.

Plus, she’s right, you know. You probably aren’t any good at catching birds and small rodents. And, most certainly, your cat wouldn’t understand your explanation about not wanting to learn in the first place. We suggest you “agree to disagree” on this matter. Resolve to implement our strategies for minimizing the number of future incidents and concentrate instead on enjoying your kitty’s other, more redeeming qualities.

Debbie Clason
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Debbie Clason's work has appeared in Family Life Magazine, Sports Illustrated, The Lutheran Witness, Massage Magazine…
Your Christmas tree can be dangerous to your pet — here’s what to know
How to keep your pets (and your tree) safe this holiday season
A white cat with black spots sits beneath a Christmas tree surrounded by lit-up fairy lights

The holiday season is the most wonderful time of the year, but that doesn't mean it's free of dangers or stressors. In fact, some holiday events and decorations pose an even larger threat to your pet's well-being than you realize. Curious kitties can get tangled in Christmas lights, and food-motivated dogs can steal something from the table that's toxic to them. This isn't a reason to be afraid, but it is important to be mindful and intentional when bringing the holidays into your home.
Are Christmas trees toxic to cats or dogs? This Yuletide symbol is one of the most common holiday decorations, but they pose several risks to pets. Fortunately, we'll review them all so that you can keep your four-legged friends safe this December. You'll be Christmas shopping before you know it!

Are Christmas trees toxic to cats?

Read more
Can cats eat pecans? What you need to know about feeding your feline this tree nut
Are pecans toxic to cats? What to know before using nut as a treat
Himalayan cat getting a treat

Pecan pie is a holiday table staple. The tree nut is also a favorite ingredient in holiday cookies and a delicious, filling year-round snack for humans. Cat parents know they need to care about the types of foods they leave out. Even the best food storage practices require thinking one or two steps ahead of your mischievous, curious, and feisty feline.

The added work is essential — some foods are toxic to cats, such as macadamia nuts. However, not all foods, including quintessential holiday dishes like turkey, are poisonous to cats. Can cats eat pecans? Unlike a tuxedo cat, the answer to this question isn't black and white. We'll scratch below the surface to give you the nuanced answer on whether cats can — and importantly, should — eat pecans.
Can cats eat pecans?

Read more
Can cats have turkey? Here’s what to know and some tips on the cats and the holiday staple
How to prepare Thanksgiving turkey for cats
A fluffy cat on top of pumpkins

With the crisp outside air, the National Dog Show on TV, and a feast waiting on the dining room table, it's hard not to feel festive. Odds are, your pets are getting in the Thanksgiving mood, too! Plenty of cats and dogs are drawn to the kitchen in late November, and it's easy to see why.
But can cats have turkey on Thanksgiving? It's only natural to want to share holiday festivities (and turkey) with your furry friend, and Thanksgiving dinner is no different. Fortunately, you'll be glad to know that many human foods are approved for feline consumption, too. You may have to prepare ingredients a certain way, so read carefully!

Can cats eat Thanksgiving turkey?

Read more