Skip to main content

Is a Christmas puppy a good idea? Why you should think twice

Here's what to know before you bring a puppy home this holiday

Woman snuggling Samoyed puppy in front of the Christmas tree
Alena Gan / Shutterstock

Of all the viral holiday videos to make their way around the internet, there’s nothing quite as heartwarming (and adorable) as watching someone meet their brand-new puppy on Christmas morning. It’s easy to see why many families feel inspired to get this surprise present for their loved ones, but should you show up with a new furry friend during the holidays?

Getting a puppy for Christmas can seem like a special, even life-changing gift, but the cleaning and work accompanying them aren’t as cute. Many families — especially kids — aren’t prepared for the effort and expense of raising a dog, which unfortunately leads to pets being dropped off at shelters not long after the holidays.

Recommended Videos

If you’re considering gifting a puppy to your family this Christmas, do the research and consider pet parenthood’s obligations. Here’s what you’ll need to know.

Why getting a puppy for Christmas isn’t always smart

A chocolate lab puppy sits patiently in front of a Christmas tree
Alina / Shutterstock

Although raising a dog can be a rewarding and joyful experience, it also requires work, patience, and responsibility. Is your family ready to take this on? Are you willing to pick up the slack if they prove they’re not?

According to the shelter staff at the Marion County Humane Society in West Virginia, shelter admissions tend to increase at the end of January every year. Unfortunately, many of these pets are Christmas gifts families weren’t ready to care for.

“People that got a new puppy or a new kitten, and they expect their young child to take care of them,” one shelter tech told WDTV. “Of course, if the kid doesn’t do it, the parent doesn’t want to take care of them, either.”

A lack of research is also a huge factor in unsuccessful pet adoptions. Not all dog breeds are easy to train or appropriate for certain lifestyles, so consulting an expert or doing some reading is vital before taking action. And remember — a cute, tiny puppy can still grow into a huge, rambunctious dog (depending on their breed), so you’ll need to be prepared.

It’s also important to consider where you’re adopting your new pup from because not all breeders are reliable. As awful as it is to acknowledge, some people sell sick and injured dogs for a quick buck. Needless to say, a dog with health concerns can be as loving of a companion as any other — after treatment, of course — but you have a right to be informed about the condition of your new friend, including information about the puppy’s parents and health history. Consider this one more reason not to support backyard breeders.

Shelters can help you get to know your pup before bringing him home, but rescued dogs will still need some extra time to adjust to their surroundings. The honeymoon phase may not be as happy-go-lucky as you expect, especially if there has been any past trauma for your pup. If this is the case, don’t be upset if your new dog isn’t matching the Holly Jolly spirit! It can take weeks, even months, before an adopted dog feels 100% at home.

What to consider before getting a puppy for Christmas

A Jack Russell Terrier wearing a Santa hat sits in a Christmas present in front of a tree
Evgenia Tiplyashina / Shutterstock

Identifying your expectations before bringing a furry friend home for the holidays is important. Who will feed the dog, and when? Who will walk them and clean up accidents? Can your partner, parents, or children take on these responsibilities? Just as importantly — can you?

Every pet deserves access to reliable healthcare, food, water, shelter, exercise, and love, so you must ensure your family can provide all these resources. This may include multiple mealtimes and walks per day, frequent restocking of food and supplies, and lots of training. It can be difficult to keep up if there’s no one at home all day or if the pet’s primary caregiver is a younger child, so this is certainly something to think through.

Do your research into the average price of dog food, vet visits, and any other costs of dog ownership to ensure your pet never has to go without care. Budgeting for a pet sitter, kennel service, groomer, and any other extra pet necessities is also important. They can add up to more than you think!

Most importantly, you and your family must be prepared with patience and an open mind. No two dogs are the same, even within the same breed, so it’s impossible to predict exactly what your new fur baby will behave like. It will take some time to get to know one another, no matter how old your pup is.

Fostering for the holidays

A dog and cat cuddle under a blanket together in front of a Christmas tree and presents
New Africa / Shutterstock

Whether you’re feeling confident or on the fence about a lifelong commitment, you may want to look into fostering a shelter dog for the holiday season. Not only is a foster home a life-changing gift for the dog, but it creates more room in shelters to save other dogs, too. You’ll get the chance to help a rescue dog decompress and gain confidence in a home environment, and you don’t need to make a decade-long commitment right away. Besides, ‘foster failing,’ or adopting your foster dog, is always an option!

To see if fostering is right for you, you’ll want to look up your local animal shelter. Many shelters and rescues provide foster information and applications online, but you can always call or visit with extra questions. Before you know it, you’ll have four more paws at home to help you ring in Christmas.

Alternatives to a Christmas puppy that require less work

A French Bulldog puppy surrounded by Christmas decor
Karsten Winegeart / Unsplash

Instead of purchasing or adopting a new four-legged friend as a Yuletide surprise, you can use the holiday season to help get your family used to having a pet around. To keep the element of surprise, you can announce to your family that you’re ready to get a puppy on Christmas morning. This way, they can have the holiday excitement while still being involved with the entire process.

For kids who still need some practice before caring for a dog, gifting a stuffed animal can be a great way to go. The plushie will symbolize the responsibilities and love to come while still providing the comfort and joy that animals give. Older kids may even be ready to take care of a pet with fewer needs, such as a pair of goldfish, though please do your research to ensure you can give any animal a happy life.

If you’ve concluded that you’re not ready to add four more paws to the family, animal lovers might appreciate a donation to a local animal shelter. You can even go shopping for dog toys, treats, blankets, and anything else shelter pets could use. A shelter dog’s Christmas gift could change so much for them!

Although some Christmas puppies end up surrendered to the shelter, many also end up as loving (and loved) lifelong companions. These success stories are often filled with patient and knowledgeable dog owners, though even the best pet parents encounter a few bumps in the road — that’s normal! Once you think through all these necessities, you’ll likely have a pretty good sense of whether getting a puppy for Christmas will be a smart idea for your home.

Gabrielle LaFrank
Gabrielle LaFrank has written for sites such as Psych2Go, Elite Daily, and, currently, PawTracks. When she's not writing, you…
Should you adopt your foster pet? Pros and cons of foster adoption
Foster fails: Should you make your foster pet a forever friend?
A couple on the couch with a puppy

You swore your foster dog or cat was a temporary resident in your home. Yet, you find yourself smitten by your foster pet. Their antics bring on all the belly laughs. Their snuggles epitomize the idea of "warm and fuzzies." Suddenly, you're coming around to the idea of making your foster pet a forever family member.

There's a lighthearted term for this occurrence: Foster fail. Despite the word "fail," the term refers to people giving a formerly homeless pet the best life. Deciding to adopt a pet you fostered can be rewarding. However, there are pros and cons worth considering first. Adopting a pet is a long-term commitment, and you want to ensure you and your potential foster fail are set up for success. Consider this guide a gut check before you adopt a foster dog or cat.
The pros and cons of adopting a foster pet

Read more
Looking for cute dog names? Try these incredible ideas
This list of adorable names will help you pick a moniker
Weimaraner puppy with blue eyes sits and looks up

There are a lot of decisions to make when you bring home a new pet, but one of the first things to decide is their name. Some shelter dogs may come to you with a name already, but many dog owners choose to start life anew with a whole new moniker to call their new puppy pal. But how in the world can you decide what to name them?
You simply have to read over these cute dog names! Whether your new companion is big or small, old or young, one of these sweet, classic names is bound to fit them. Of course, take your time while in the throes of this process and do what feels right to you. You truly can't go wrong!
30 cute dog names for females

These are some of the most popular girl dog names in recent years. They may have been used before, but there's no doubt that they're classic and cute.

Read more
When do puppies open their eyes? What you need to know
You'll experience a lot of exciting firsts as the owner of a brand-new puppy
Litter of nursing puppies

If you've just become a surrogate parent to a litter of puppies, you have a lot of amazing firsts before you. While the first real bowel movement that you wind up scooping and first walk after their vaccines might be the most memorable, you'll also never forget when your new pupper opens their eyes for the first time.

Like so many mammals, these bundles of joy are born underdeveloped compared to some of our distant cousins, like turtles that make a break for the ocean and take care of themselves within hours of emerging from the egg. So when do puppies open their eyes? We'll walk you through what that looks like.
When do puppies open their eyes?

Read more